Benchmarking the Same Frame in SAP2000 and ETABS
Use the same mass, material, section and restraint inputs. Use the example below to practice the review and record an output that another reviewer can reproduce.
Inputs and Prerequisites
Two isolated test models, matched support and loading assumptions, and documented program defaults.
Review Workflow
- Common benchmark
- Program settings
- Reaction comparison
- Difference log
- Use the same mass, material, section and restraint inputs.
- Disable or document automated self-weight and analysis options.
- Compare reactions and a selected response before adding complexity.
Worked Example
An idealized single-span beam takes a 10 kN midspan load. Its reference reactions are 5 kN each. A model returning 6 kN at both supports has 2 kN additional net vertical action. Check self-weight and loading before comparing stiffness.
Output Checks and Common Errors
Compare local axes, offsets and released degrees of freedom after force equilibrium closes.
Official References
- CSI Analysis Reference Manual
Check how the software represents supports, distributed loads and analysis conventions.